Many people who use potentially dangerous tools have done stupid things that could have caused harm to themselves or others. Should they all not be allowed to touch those tools again?
Theres a big difference, between, say, something which is
truly an "accident" and something which is full blown negligence.
Discharging a gun unintentionally because you got hit by a piece of hot brass
tends to cross the line into negligence territory. She probably had her
finger on the trigger when this happened. Had she obeyed at least that
rule (taking her finger off the trigger) she would not have shot herself.
This isn't all that much different than say, a person who spills coffee in their
lap while driving and lets go of the steering wheel to tend to the spill, and
their car shoots across 4 lanes of traffic. A piece of hot brass is
generally NOT life threatening. It's not -that- hard to make safe in
some manner or another and then deal with whatever the issue
was. Even if she couldn't put the gun down, she could have at least
indexed her finger alongside the gun and held it at the ground or pointed
it downrange while she used her other hand to do the "fidgeting".
I guess it's just a mindset thing more than anything else. I've been
stung by a bee while shooting, and while that was unpleasant, I didn't
endanger anyone else in the process of "dealing with it". I've also been
hit by a ricochet, as well, and at no time did the muzzle go astray enough
to put someone else in danger or did I accidentally discharge a shot.
As far as punishment goes, I dunno. In this case because she hurt
herself I think she was punished enough, but if she had hurt someone
else, perhaps charges of some sort would be appropriate.
An "accident" at a shooting range is a piece of jacketing or other debris
coming back from someone else's shot and hitting someone. Shooting
yourself or someone else because of a stupid piece of hot brass is negligence,
pure and simple.
EDIT: FWIW, btw, I -have- had an entire dunkin donuts large coffee explode
in my hand/lap about a couple months ago (the lid was not properly seated or
something was wrong with the cup) and while it was painful, I was still able
to safely take my car off the highway without endangering someone else.
The whole thing sucked, I had to drive back home and change my clothes before
I went to work again...
At least nobody was seriously
hurt.
-Mike