Those are about as different as different gets in a 9mm semi-auto. I'll admit that I tried to find (and buy) a METE SFT in black recently, but couldn't find one in MA just yet. I am a relative newcomer to the Canik line (and a long-time Canik skeptic/holdout), but so far so good with the other Caniks I currently own, including a Rival.
The 1911 is a 1911... and as much as I am perfectly fine with .45 ACP 1911's, for some reason 9mm in a 1911 has never worked for me. Be sure to try one out before you jump. You may find yourself in the same boat.
I am only buying optic-ready pistols these days, so my decision between the two would be very easy.