Practice or Training?

Joined
Nov 2, 2005
Messages
5,872
Likes
221
Location
North Central MA
Feedback: 19 / 0 / 0
From: http://www.usashooting.com/modules....s&file=index&req=viewarticle&artid=172&page=1


No. 6 - Practice or Training?
On the Firing Line (Sixth in a series - July 2001)

Practice, or Training?
2001 JP O'Connor



The notes are as clear in my memory as when they were last played thirty years ago. Masterfully played o*n the piano by my mother, Ernesto Lacuono's Malaguea is a complex and wonderfully moving piece of music. She would sit down and, without a thought or any music in front of her, launch into a performance of the full version worthy of a concert pianist. The dynamics and tempo changes to fit the music were beyond compare, and the passion and feeling of the music - indeed the music itself - flowed from her fingers into the instrument and out into the room. o*ne could not listen without being moved.

Years later, while exploring aspects of ultimate performance (music, dance, ice skating, swimming, weight lifting, pole vaulting, shooting - it's all the same), I discussed her piano performance with my mother. In the course of the conversation she made a most interesting comment: "I was never a great pianist. I was just well practiced."

She went o*n to explain that she had worked hard to learn a number of difficult pieces very well, which allowed her to perform them expertly. However, if handed a new piece, she would have had to work laboriously to bring it up to the same standards - unlike a master pianist who would do it rather quickly and easily.

Have you ever seen a football game? Have you ever seen a football practice? How about a baseball or basketball game and their practice sessions? Have you ever seen how these athletes train? Does their game look like their practice? Of course not! Have you ever seen a shooting competition? How about a shooting practice? More often than not, they look the same! What's going o*n here?

The vast majority of shooters, at least in this country, spend most of their practice time doing exactly what they do in a match: get into position and shoot for score. They are "well practiced" shooters. The "well practiced" performer knows how to do certain things very well. Regardless of whether it is music at the piano or shots toward a target, o*ne can repeat the process over and over and, through trial and error, eventually learn to perform fairly well. This is a time consuming and frustrating process.

This also results in the performer reaching a plateau that limits their potential. It becomes impossible to reach higher levels of performance without completely relearning the techniques and approaching the game from another perspective. Athletes who are already o*n a national team or competing o*n the international level are not willing to break their game and rebuild it all over. The problem is that it is possible to reach these levels while being o*nly well practiced.

The few athletes that seem to be so much better than most often have a much different understanding of the game and much more knowledge of it. You know that you need to be balanced, but do you know how to check it and actually set it up right? You may have been told about inner position, but do you really know what it is and how to sense and use it? You know correct natural point of aim (NPA) is important, but do you know how to really and truly check it? (If you don't know those first two, then you don't really know this o*ne!) You know it is important to remain calm and relaxed, but do you know how to calm and relax yourself - physically, mentally, and emotionally - in a matter of moments in the heat of the match - or while the clock is running down o*n a finals shot? Do you tire easily in the course of several matches? The list goes o*n and o*n.

As for practice time, do you merely practice or do you train? Do you ever do drills to build your awareness of balance, inner position, and NPA? What about drills that allow you to focus o*n consistency and feel rather than score? How about drills that build your confidence while increasing your ability to break a shot automatically after a very short hold? We give lip service to the fact that our sport is 90% or 95% (or some large percent) mental. Yet, what do we spend 90% or 95% or 100% of our practice time o*n? The physical and technical game! Are you a conscious control shooter? Do you believe that is the way to Olympic gold? After all, in our culture we are taught from a young age to pay attention and concentrate when we want to do something perfectly. Yet that is not the way to do it! Cultural pressure often prevents us from finding better ways. Instead, do you trust yourself enough to relinquish conscious control to your inner self and allow the shots to unfold? Do you know how to do this - or even believe in it?

Admittedly, some of these ideas are controversial. After all, there are any number of shooters who are well practiced, who utilize conscious shot control, and who usually o*nly shoot for score in practice that have done well. Some even make the national team and win medals in international competition. Some of these are rare individuals who just happen to have the right mix of skills to go along with their hard work; for others it's just hard work and determination.

Yet we watch groups of shooters from other countries (China, Korea, Germany, among others), and an occasional shooter from our country, dominate the medal standings. What is the difference? The dominant shooters usually have a deeper understanding of the game. They have come to understand the concepts being discussed here and find ultimate performance to be almost effortless, even in an important match. They do drills that build skills, skills that translate into improved and more consistent performance, performance that translates into higher scores. They never work o*n score. They almost always allow their shots to happen for them - almost as a detached spectator - rather than with conscious control that strives for a "perfect" shot. The conscious mind is too slow!

Deciding that becoming a better shooter is just a matter of more practice is the slow, unreliable, high risk path to ultimate performance. What got you to your current level may not be - indeed probably is not - what you need to get to the next level, or the next several levels. Even among my own students, I see some who understand this and others who look at me like I'm nuts!

As a national team coach said to me during a discussion about a number of up and coming young shooters, "The o*nes that make the changes now are the o*nes that will do well in 2004 and 2008." Are you working to be a great shooter?

Or are you merely well practiced?
 
Practice or Training?

Just a few of my thoughts on this:

One of the aspects of practice is repeating a motion or drill or situation so that you can repeat what you have done in practice during a performance. Honestly that is what a match is; a performance or test if you will. Get the best score you can in the shortest time possible.

If my understanding of history and philosophy of war craft is correct, a warrior or martial artist is one who can adapt to situations as they are presented. Drills and a pre-senerio walk though are great, you will know what is expected of you during the thirty seconds of engagement.

But what about walking on the street? Are you aware of what is going on around you?

I have come up with training situations that have thrown some people for a loop. One scenario that I had at Pelham was to walk out of a store to your car, like you normally would on any given day. I gave the shooter a plastic bag with empty boxes inside, told them “here is the door to the store, there is a pole here and that chair is the drivers seat of you car. Leave the store and get into your car.

Granted I had a pretty good idea of what was to happen in my head and in retrospect my directions were simple, though they may not have been effectively conveyed. I am still working on the best way to replicate the “real world” in a competition or practice

The first few people asked me what was going to happen and which targets were going to be “the bad guys?” and “what can I do with this bag you are making me carry?” To both of these questions I answered “You will know when I do,” and “It’s your milk and eggs I don’t care what you do with them.”

People adapted differently to this. Some acted like they were being evaluated on how they walked and acted in an exaggerated lackadaisical state; others started walking to their “car” like they were ready to shoot someone. Only when I stopped them and questioned them about what they were doing did they realize that this wasn’t normal behavior for anyone. Maybe at some point I will start a psychology paper and testing on this, but for now I will just make some general observations.

We, myself included, practice as gamers; we do not have the ability to be the “wandering warrior,” if such ever existed; going about the country side righting wrong where ever we may encounter it, as shown in popular myth and television. What we have is a sensationalized version of this through IPSC, IDPA and weeknight practices.

Does this lessen what we do? Not in the least bit. It is what we have, to the point, as the only outlet as a modern civilian warrior.

The question is: Can we live in a society that ensues what we do even though they see it as abnormal for society?

Can we still pick up our sword and fly?
 
Back
Top Bottom