I am in love...

[Broc]

The Hornady version looks easier to use, but maybe a bit longer to set up than the RCBS one. (Based only on the two videos posted here)

Any compelling reason to get the RCBS version?

I forget why I got the RCBS, but I had it set up in like 3 minutes.

I couldn't find the 9mm shell holder so I set it up in the Dillon. Took me 3minutes because I had to remove a die.

I had the Dillon set for 45ACP and it worked fine for 360DW (same as 357).

 

[ddeck]

I forget why I got the RCBS, but I had it set up in like 3 minutes.

I couldn't find the 9mm shell holder so I set it up in the Dillon. Took me 3minutes because I had to remove a die.

I had the Dillon set for 45ACP and it worked fine for 360DW (same as 357).

It’s green. The color of Broccoli.

 

[enbloc]

Never used the Hornady, but it looks nice.

I'll let you know. I'm pulling down M2 Garand ammo with it...

 

[enbloc]

The Hornady version looks easier to use, but maybe a bit longer to set up than the RCBS one. (Based only on the two videos posted here)

Any compelling reason to get the RCBS version?

The RCBS is 10-15 bucks cheaper...

 

[enbloc]

After a quick check, the Hornady only offers collets for rifle cartridges, RCBS offers both Rifle and Pistol collets...

Big flexibility difference...

From MidwayUSA's Description:

The Hornady Cam-Lock Bullet Puller is the ideal tool for reloaders wanting a fast, easy way to pull bullets with their press. Simply raise the cartridge into the puller, clamp the puller down on the bullet, raise the press arm and presto, the bullet is out. Intended for rifle cartridges only.

 

[milktree]

The RCBS is 10-15 bucks cheaper...

So, The Interwebs says the RCBS is better all around:

RCBS Bullet Puller vs Hornady Bullet Puller - The Reloaders Network

TATV Canada - RCBS Bullet Puller vs Hornady Bullet Puller

www.thereloadersnetwork.com

I’d like to see a lever like cam thingie on the RCBS, as that would speed up operation

 

[enbloc]

So, The Interwebs says the RCBS is better all around:

RCBS Bullet Puller vs Hornady Bullet Puller - The Reloaders Network

TATV Canada - RCBS Bullet Puller vs Hornady Bullet Puller

www.thereloadersnetwork.com

I’d like to see a lever like cam thingie on the RCBS, as that would speed up operation

That's what I was thinking. Cam would be faster and not wear on the screw threads like the RCBS.

 

[enbloc]

Here is a vote for RCBS video...

 

[enbloc]

Ok. I little more interneting says the Hornady Cam loc will work on pistol rounds that have enough flatness in the diameter above the case-mouth.

Here is a vid on the Hornady showing it is action:

 

[DW357]

After a quick check, the Hornady only offers collets for rifle cartridges, RCBS offers both Rifle and Pistol collets...

Big flexibility difference...

From MidwayUSA's Description:

No you can get collets for pistol calibers too. I have one for 9mm. But I think the Hornady puller works “better” with rifle bullets

 

[76Too]

RCBS

Are the dies the same as the collet puller type? I bought some in the early spring before I left Indy, but I couldn’t figure out how to use them my first time. Everything got packed up after a ‘college try’/failed attempt.

 

[enbloc]

No you can get collets for pistol calibers too. I have one for 9mm. But I think the Hornady puller works “better” with rifle bullets

Yeah, a collet is a collet, I guess. Both manufactures said "May deform cast bullets..." But they melt up again pretty easy.

 

[Broc]

Are the dies the same as the collet puller type? I bought some in the early spring before I left Indy, but I couldn’t figure out how to use them my first time. Everything got packed up after a ‘college try’/failed attempt.

Not sure if I understand what you are asking.

The RCBS is a die + a collet bullet puller.

The die holds the collets. Changing calibers takes under a minute.

 

[Broc]

No you can get collets for pistol calibers too. I have one for 9mm. But I think the Hornady puller works “better” with rifle bullets

I forget why I got the RCBS, but I did a lot of reading before getting one. If I got it, it is because most people in other forums recommended it.

I bought it like 4 months ago and just got around to use it so I don't remember all the details.

 

[enbloc]

I like the Hornady because it reminds me of a beer tap...

 

[Broc]

So, The Interwebs says the RCBS is better all around:

RCBS Bullet Puller vs Hornady Bullet Puller - The Reloaders Network

TATV Canada - RCBS Bullet Puller vs Hornady Bullet Puller

www.thereloadersnetwork.com

I’d like to see a lever like cam thingie on the RCBS, as that would speed up operation

You literally move it maybe 1/16th of a turn. It doesn't require a lot of pressure. Not sure how much faster one would be over the other.

 

[enbloc]

I am looking at the RCBS now and may order it with calibers that I didn't order for the Hornady (.224 & .308),
and will evaluate for myself. After I decide what works best for me, I'll fill in the blank calibers for the model I choose. Good times...

 

[enbloc]

Done.

 

[PL-52]

While we’re talking about add ons and such I didn’t like the tube hanging down from the press, so I directed it into a jug that holds way more and never gets snagged on anything.

 

[Mike 53]

The best thing to strike them against is the end grain of a piece of oak or other hardwood. It will dislodge the bullet but won't chip the plastic like concrete will.

Or in my case the smooth upper part of my 6" bench vise...

 

[ddeck]

While we’re talking about add ons and such I didn’t like the tube hanging down from the press, so I directed it into a jug that holds way more and never gets snagged on anything.View attachment 677457

I'm using this in conjunction with a 2 liter bottle. Now when I knock it over I don't scream obscenities:

Thingiverse - Digital Designs for Physical Objects

Download files and build them with your 3D printer, laser cutter, or CNC.

www.thingiverse.com

 

[PL-52]

Sometimes with coated bullets you just have to go old school! 12x6x2” block of steel, about 50 lbs worth.

 

[PL-52]

I'm using this in conjunction with a 2 liter bottle. Now when I knock it over I don't scream obscenities:

Thingiverse - Digital Designs for Physical Objects

Download files and build them with your 3D printer, laser cutter, or CNC.

www.thingiverse.com

Nice. But with the Lee Press the tube moves with the handle up and down.

 

[76Too]

Not sure if I understand what you are asking.

The RCBS is a die + a collet bullet puller.

The die holds the collets. Changing calibers takes under a minute.

I’m not sure I understand what I’m asking either. Maybe I should find the damn thing in my boxes before I ask any stupid questions about it?

I finally got my 800lb safe in my basement when my dad came to visit last weekend, so the reloading room setup finally got cleared for takeoff as soon as the weather turns and I don’t feel like spending more than a few hours outside.

 

[gerrycaruso]

I use both. The hammer works well for large heavy bullets but lousy for small light bullets like .223.

 

[pastera]

Nice. But with the Lee Press the tube moves with the handle up and down.

Add a telescoping section

 

[PL-52]

See photo I inserted the clear tube 7 or 8” into the pvc pipe it rides up and down inside there.

 

[TrashcanDan]

Here is a vote for RCBS video...

Yeah, a collet is a collet, I guess. Both manufactures said "May deform cast bullets..." But they melt up again pretty easy.

Outstanding.
I was waiting to see if anyone used it for plated 230's and coated 158-170's.
I have a few hundred .38's to pull thanks to Black Bullets and the .45 cases I can salvage

 

[Jay77]

See if you only had a kid to use the impact puller. I use a piece of scrap 2x4 when I have to pull the occasional bullet. But I might have to grab one of these when I run out of LPP because I have an ammo can of bullets waiting to be pulled.

 

[Road_Clam]

Now you know.

This is the one:

Standard Bullet Puller without Collet | RCBS

Buy Standard Bullet Puller without Collet at RCBS, the leading producer of high-quality reloading equipment supplies for over 60 years.

www.rcbs.com

Very easy to use.

I have the same one, keep in mind the caliber specific collet may not fit the bullet ogive contour perfect and the collets can slip off . Ive also had a hard time pulling nato crimped bullets and they may , or may not leave collet indents in the surface. The inertia type hammer pullers extract totally clean with no indents but i agree with you inertia hammers can be a real pia to get the bullet to extract . I hammer my puller off a thick oak block of wood.