Im currently shopping for a crossbow. Anyone here have solid hunting experience (good or bad) with any particular models/brands?
I have an Excalibur Exocet recurve crossbow and it is great. I can change my own strings in the field if needed and no press is required for anything. Reserving the serving is a piece of cake as I can take the string off , reserve it, and then put it back on. After the season I take the string off and let the limbs relax during the summer months.
Their warranty is awesome. I bought mine used and it had a problem in the trigger unit. I called them and explained the problem, told them that I bought it used, and told them I wanted to buy a replacement trigger unit. Their reply was "Send it in and we will take care of it." The crossbow was back on my doorstep fixed in 5 days and all it cost me was the freight. One of the best features of my Excal is that once cocked it doesn't have to be fired, it can just be let down with the cocking rope.
I shot 3 deer with my Excal last year and all arrows were pass thru's 2 of the three arrows were buried in the ground up to the fletchings after the pass thru. One was only buried 1/2 way in the dirt as it hit a tree root.
My dad has a Parker Terminator HP 175lb and he has had no problems with it either. Connecticut has a 200lb limit on crossbows if you are interested in hunting Connecticut.
My recommendation would be to stay with a mainstream crossbow brand and you should be fine. I still see quite a few complaints about Barnett crossbows but the word is that they are working hard to overcome their past reputation.
Recurve crossbows are wider than compounds, but no press is needed for working on them. I have not been to an archery shop in 3 years as I do everything myself.
All crossbows are loud. Some more than others and IMO they can't be quieted enough to make a difference to a deer.
All crossbows are awkward to carry in the woods.
IMO The effective range for a crossbow is the same as for a vertical bow for all intents and purposes. I have shot deer out to 40 yards with most of my kills being at the 20 yard mark.
If you hunt on the ground as I do a monopod can be a useful accessory. There are monopods (Stoney point for example) that attach to the sling swivel on the stock.
Keep your thumb below the string. It really smarts.
There are a lot of good folks and some good reading over on crossbow nation:
http://www.crossbownation.com/index.php
The best advice I can give you is to go down to Cabela's or Bass pro and shoot some to see what feels comfortable to you.
If I can be of any help let me know.
Bob