animal, I'm the VP of a club (not one of the ones mentioned in this thread). I have 200+ hours of firearms training, including LFI-1 and 2, Sigarms Concealed Carry and Advanced Concealed Carry, Cumberland Tactics Tactical Handgun 101. I'm an NRA certified instructor. IDPA certified safety officer. NRA certified Range Safety Officer. I've competed in IDPA and NRA service rifle. I don't consider myself to be an expert, but I do have knowledge that many of our club members do not have.
I don't view everyone else as incompetent. But if you come to my club, I can show bullet holes in the walls and ceiling baffles of our indoor range. I can show you bullet holes in the backstop on our outdoor range, 4 feet above where targets are posted. I can show you the wood we had to replace on our outdoor range where a member placed empty water bottles on the wood retaining the sand for our backstop. Said individual fired too quickly for his skill, pulling his shots low and damaging the wood. He then left the water bottles on the ground, for someone else to clean up. This is the type of crap that officers at a gun club have to deal with. Over and over again.
That is your opinion. I respect it. But the reality is that a single incident can shut a club down for good. If someone is injured on our range, I fully expect to be sued, and that nightmare will continue for years. The liability is real and should not be minimized. The Westfield Gun Club is currently facing criminal charges as the result of an incident.
I'm sorry, but I think you are minimizing the risk here. There is far more risk involved in drawing and reholstering than there is with simple bullseye shooting. Well trained people can and do screw up and shoot themselves in the leg. This has happened seven times at Front Sight, under the supervision of qualified instructors:
http://www.frontsight.com/SafetyReports.asp?Action=ShowSingle&ID=5
There are clubs where you can do what you're looking for. I think Pelham is one of those clubs.
But I'll ask you to please give the officers at a club a little more benefit of the doubt. The issue of liability is far more severe than you are implying. I'm not saying that clubs should or should not allow defensive practice. What I'm saying is that I fully understand why some clubs take a very conservative approach to this.