• If you enjoy the forum please consider supporting it by signing up for a NES Membership  The benefits pay for the membership many times over.

Amazon "Smile" and Comm2A

I wish there was some sort of confirmation or icon that the order was successfully done via a charity (Comm2A) I ordered via the amazon link on their site yesterday but have NO CLUE if it worked or not...
It works.

The Amazon referral program is designed (by Amazon) to be low key. Comm2a is not even allowed to post a notice on www.comm2a.org stating that it gets $$ for purchases through the link.

You will not get a notice that a commission was paid. It's similar to car sales or life insurance - you never get a notice from the vendor "Your salesperson was paid $X in comission for this sale".

Amazon pays an even higher percentage if we link to specific products. You'll see this on product review sites where they compare several treadmills (or whatever) purporting to be neutral, and have a comissioned Amazon link to each of the compared products.
 
Last edited:
Most 2A organizations are not charitable. They are non-profits but not 501(c)(3)s.

(in case it is not obvious, that's why the NH orgs are not on there; lobbying beyond a modest amount is forbidden to 501(c)(3)s and all the NH orgs actively lobby - comm2A is a 501(c)(3) and has to tread that line with care)
 
Last edited:
It works.

The Amazon referral program is designed (by Amazon) to be low key. Comm2a is not even allowed to post a notice on www.comm2a.org stating that it gets $$ for purchases through the link.


I'll trust you then. Comm2A getting 5% of my amazon purchases means they should easily be getting $100-200 a year just from me :)
 
I'll do that Smile thing for sure and try to remember the link, but honestly I probably will forget the link a lot. It'd be nice if there was an automatic way.
 
I'll do that Smile thing for sure and try to remember the link, but honestly I probably will forget the link a lot. It'd be nice if there was an automatic way.

Save Comm2a as a favorite in your browser but name it Amazon, can't forget once that is done. [smile]
 
Smiles also doesn't list any NH 2A organizations in it's list. So F that noise.
That's either because they're not a 501(c)(3) or no one has added them to the list. With Comm2A someone designed Comm2A and then we had to verity our status.

Save Comm2a as a favorite in your browser but name it Amazon, can't forget once that is done. [smile]
This is the easiest thing to do.

It's important to understand the difference between the two programs. Amazon Smile is strictly for non-profit whereas anyone can be an Amazon affiliate. The affiliate program is a referral partnerships. The money Comm2A receives from AmazonSmile is a donation from Amazon. The money Comm2A receives from the affiliate program (preferred) is a commission for business steered to Amazon.
 
It works.

The Amazon referral program is designed (by Amazon) to be low key. Comm2a is not even allowed to post a notice on www.comm2a.org stating that it gets $$ for purchases through the link.

That's odd. Look at Instapundit. Upper right hand corner, that's a pretty obvious advertisement that he gets money from Amazon if people click through his site.

- - - Updated - - -

Smiles also doesn't list any NH 2A organizations in it's list. So F that noise.

You probably want to take that up with the organizations, not Amazon.
 
That's odd. Look at Instapundit. Upper right hand corner, that's a pretty obvious advertisement that he gets money from Amazon if people click through his site.
I didn't say that all vendors complied, or that Amazon enforces the policy - but the last time I checked, it was in the terms for the affiliate program.
 
Smiles also doesn't list any NH 2A organizations in it's list. So F that noise.

So use the Comm2A link and help out your brothers to the south. The more successful we are the less you have to fight the transplants turning NH into MA North.
 
Threadus ressurectus!

(My best Harry Potter impression.)

Not necroposting too deeply, I figured this was more appropriate than a new thread. All the players are here.


Yestereve I was greeted with a popup on Amazon, when using the Comm2A link, directing me to use Smile.

attachment.php



Has anyone else seen this? Does this mean that the big-percentage direct link is obsolete and only the half-percent option remains?
 

Attachments

  • amazonsmile.gif
    amazonsmile.gif
    22.9 KB · Views: 58
Yestereve I was greeted with a popup on Amazon, when using the Comm2A link, directing me to use Smile.

attachment.php



Has anyone else seen this? Does this mean that the big-percentage direct link is obsolete and only the half-percent option remains?

I've seen it, and I always stay on Amazon so Comm2A gets 5% instead of the 1/2% Smile pays. I don't think anything has changed with the percentage they get. Amazon is just offering another option, but you don't have to take it.

I clicked "Don't show me this again."
 
Last edited:
Yes this is an old thread but when I couldn't find the Amazon link on their website, I emailed Comm2A to see which was the best way to donate, Smile or shop.Comm2a.org.

Their reply:

"You should probably just go with Smile at this point. That's an actual donation that Amazon makes to us.

We don't really take part in the affiliate program any more. That's a referral, not a donation program."


This guidance came as a surprise to me, but it's direct from Comm2A. It's to bad too, because I just bought a whole bunch of stuff using the shop.comm2a.org link.
 
This year [smile] :

Amazon


Dear Paul,

This is the quarterly notification to inform you that AmazonSmile has made a charitable donation to the charity you’ve selected, Commonwealth Second Amendment Inc, in the amount of $1,427.62 as a result of qualifying purchases made by you and other customers who have selected this charity.

Thanks to customers shopping at smile.amazon.com, or with AmazonSmile ON in the Amazon Shopping app, everyday purchases have generated over $346 million in donations to charities worldwide so far.

AmazonSmile's impact:​
  • $19,557.48 to Commonwealth Second Amendment Inc*
  • Over $306 million to US charities
  • Over $346 million to charities worldwide

To track donations or change your charity, simply visit Your AmazonSmile Impact page.​


 
Dear customer,

In 2013, we launched AmazonSmile to make it easier for customers to support their favorite charities. However, after almost a decade, the program has not grown to create the impact that we had originally hoped. With so many eligible organizations—more than 1 million globally—our ability to have an impact was often spread too thin.

We are writing to let you know that we plan to wind down AmazonSmile by February 20, 2023. We will continue to pursue and invest in other areas where we’ve seen we can make meaningful change—from building affordable housing to providing access to computer science education for students in underserved communities to using our logistics infrastructure and technology to assist broad communities impacted by natural disasters.

To help charities that have been a part of the AmazonSmile program with this transition, we will be providing them with a one-time donation equivalent to three months of what they earned in 2022 through the program, and they will also be able to accrue additional donations until the program officially closes in February. Once AmazonSmile closes, charities will still be able to seek support from Amazon customers by creating their own wish lists.

As a company, we will continue supporting a wide range of other programs that help thousands of charities and communities across the U.S. For instance:
  • Housing Equity Fund: We’re investing $2 billion to build and preserve affordable housing in our hometown communities. In just two years, we’ve provided funding to create more than 14,000 affordable homes—and we expect to build at least 6,000 more in the coming months. These units will host more than 18,000 moderate- to low-income families, many of them with children. In one year alone, our investments have been able to increase the affordable housing stock in communities like Bellevue, Washington and Arlington, Virginia by at least 20%.
  • Amazon Future Engineer: We’ve funded computer science curriculum for more than 600,000 students across over 5,000 schools—all in underserved communities. We have plans to reach an additional 1 million students this year. We’ve also provided immediate assistance to 55,000 students in our hometown communities by giving them warm clothes for the winter, food, and school supplies.
  • Community Delivery Program: We’ve partnered with food banks in 35 U.S. cities to deliver more than 23 million meals, using our logistics infrastructure to help families in need access healthy food – and we plan to deliver 12 million more meals this year alone. In addition to our delivery services, we’ve also donated 30 million meals in communities across the country.
  • Amazon Disaster Relief: We’re using our logistics capabilities, inventory, and cloud technology to provide fast aid to communities affected by natural disasters. For example, we’ve created a Disaster Relief Hub in Atlanta with more than 1 million relief items ready for deployment, our Disaster Relief team has responded to more than 95 natural disasters, and we’ve donated more than 20 million relief products to nonprofits assisting communities on the ground.
  • Community Giving: We support hundreds of local nonprofits doing meaningful work in cities where our employees and their families live. For example, each year we donate hundreds of millions of dollars to organizations working to build stronger communities, from youth sport leagues, to local community colleges, to shelters for families experiencing homelessness.
We’ll continue working to make a difference in many ways, and our long-term commitment to our communities remains the same—we’re determined to do every day better for our customers, our employees, and the world at large.

Thank you for being an Amazon customer.​
 
Looks like Amazon is killing the Smile program. Sucks. Was probably a good revenue stream for Comm2A.
Decent. Not as good as it was in the beginning but then they went after those they didn't like very quickly and curtailed the undesirables. This dropping of smile seems like an extension of that from the announcement, where they tout the NPOs they will direct support. Look at the list and draw one's own conclusions...
 
Back
Top Bottom