I'd tend to agree with you. My question here is: Who was there first? If it was the shooter land owner, then Whiney McBitchface didn't do due diligence. Maybe bought the land at a discount because the previous owners moved due to noise.
If the shooter moved in second, THEN, I'd agree whole heartedly with you and shooter may not have shown respect to the OG land owners near by.
I've said it before, I'm going to know my neighbors before I move into my next home purchase. I absolutely plan on showing up with a large pizza and a 12-pack of upper tier beer. If that upsets them, I know not to move there. If they welcome me, then we move on to politics
.