Yes it is.
Maybe the movie theaters are comparable "crime" wise or "perception of crime" wise but otherwise Randolph is, for the most part, a physically nice looking town while Brockton is a run down cess pool. There are still good people in Randolph and tons of good restaurants to eat at (La Scala, Lynwood, Zacks to name a few, in addition to all the chains). We can't control the population or geography.
As somebody who lives there, you guys who are basically saying its up there with the taboo to visit towns in the state are off your rockers, sorry. I don't like the population that has moved in any more than the next person but it is not dangerous to drive through the town or walk main street at 2am.
The movie theater looks bad and the perception of crime is there but I hear very little going on there, my scanner is always on. We have an extremely good and responsive PD (mainly because we had a great chief in the 1990's) who are on top of everything that happens. Most of our bad rap comes from the youtes of a certain nationality and their weapons of choice are mostly rocks, cement, bricks and metal bars.
That said, I go to movies elsewhere because I hate being around the ignorant youtes, I'm not afraid of them though, they would not so much as bat an eye at a random person.
Randolph history:
In the late 1960s I was mugged by the brother of a Randolph PO as I pulled up to the USPO to mail a letter at ~8PM and they were rifling cars parked along the street (USPO was located in a Randolph Square back then). Although I reported it to the police and told them who it was, nothing was ever done about it.
Let's see . . . back ~1972 the town had to call in the MSP to keep order. It seems that the Rumpot Rustlers (motorcycle gang) had pretty much taken over the town. The town was over-built in a massive way but the population that you allude to had not moved into town yet.
Sometime in the 1980s, there were allegations (by LEOs that I know, they lived in Randolph but did not work there) of a major real estate firm doing "block busting". I'm not aware of the veracity of these allegations, but these people were selling their homes in Randolph and would be more aware than I about what was going on there.
As to the former police chief in the 1990s, I believe that you are referring to Jake. I knew him casually and he seemed like an OK guy. I went to school with one of his Brothers, who was a scrapper. However, Jake "snapped" and allegedly attacked one of his own officers in the parking lot and was then forced to retire. Sad, but points out that all was not well there.
The current chief is someone I went to RHS with and his late Wife graduated with me. Paul's a nice guy. I don't live there and can't pass judgment on the competence of either Paul or Jake's leadership of the PD.
The design of these "destination cinemaplexs" is such that it becomes a magnet for youts to hang around. Never a good thing anywhere, but it does keep them off the streets.
All this said:
- I've never been fearful of driving thru Randolph, even to this day.
- I would not feel comfortable wandering around Randolph Square on foot in the late evenings.
- I always keep my situational awareness in "alert mode" there.
- Brockton on the other hand, I wouldn't feel comfortable walking their downtown streets in broad daylight!
- So no, Randolph IMNSHO has not (yet) sunk to the level of Brockton (which also has some very nice neighborhoods and houses in the West Side). I hope it never does either.
Having eaten Zach's pizza a few years ago, I was disappointed . . . it was not as tasty as it was back in the late 1950s thru 1970s. Haven't been to La Scalla in years but it was always a good upscale Italian restaurant. A few good restaurants don't make a town good/great. Brockton has Christo's which is a great restaurant, but doesn't cancel out the crime issues of the city.