dcmdon will probably be along shortly to tell you that those cops are ****ing clueless. Thankfully one of them was less clueless than the other one was....
-Mike
Mike you are in good company. My wife tells me I'm very predictable. Guilty as charged.
Malavaley - The cop was &%$King clueless.
You did not have to show him any ID. You'd probably been better if you didn't show a CT PP. Actually you didnt' have to show him any ID. You weren't in possession of a firearm. No ID required.
Also, remember, a pistol permit is not required to possess a handgun in CT. Only to carry it. You were on private property. So even if you did have one of your guns on you, you could have had it there legally if you had loaned it to the property owner.
This is all so so bad. All I can suggest is know what your risk tolerance is before this happens again. Are you afraid of arrest? If so, then you did the right thing, comply with their unlawful requests. You never broke any law, and you were very . . . charitable to the offending officer.
If you are up for educating the cop, then refuse unlawful requests.
The cop was a douche. Illegal possession of a firearm in CT pretty much only applies to prohibited persons, since its legal to possess any firearm in CT without state approval, other than assault weapons.