No...you don't have to. You SHOULD have to, as there are guys that buy surplus tags for 9,10,11,12 and take does in 3,4,5,6,7,and 8. Yet report them otherwise. Most guys aren't stupid enough to try and buy an island tag and pass it off....as your going to get a visit from the Game Warden if you shoot a doe in Zone 5 and check it in Zone 5 as an island deer shot from 14 or 13.Are you supposed to check your deer in the zone where you took it? I have a few spots I may hit spread throughout 4n and 4s. My check station would be in 4S.
But around me...guys hunt in big groups and do it all the time.