Caveat: The following is all based on the assumptions that you are referring
to inline muzzleloading rifles...
This will be my first year shooting black powder. I am a Research-Aholic so
this is what I have gleaned and followed for advice...
Buy from the big names in black powder: Thompson-Center, Knight, and
Savage. NEF has a loyal following for a high quality budget rifle.
There are some questions about the quality of barrels on Spanish guns
(Traditions, CVA, Winchester), do your research and decide for yourself before you buy.
There are real steals to be had if you search. I got a Knight DISC Elite for
$225 NEW from sportsmen's guide as part of a closeout and a Burris Signature
Safari scope for $130 on ebay. The combo lists for about $900. A used Knight
or Thompson will be high quality and will definately retain its value.
4 Seasons has a somewhat beat up Knight with crappy scope for $150 IIRC.
It has been there for most of the year, I bet Carl would take an offer to
get rid of it. Clean it up, toss on a Simmons 4X scope and you are good to
go for under $200. I've seen similar deals at gun shows.
Buy a .50 cal. The shots in New England are generally short and ammo is easy
to find.
Make sure that you buy a gun with a barrel twist that matches your intended
ammo. If you are looking for a Kentucky rifle replica, it needs ~ 1:60 twist to
stabalize the balls. A 1:28 twist is generally needed for Sabot rounds.
Accuracy can range from 1" at 100 yds (the best Knights) to minute of barn
(crappy guns with mismatched twists/loads).
That said, my rig is all set up but I have to go and break it in soon.
To get you started:
http://www.chuckhawks.com/most_accurate_muzzleloaders.htm
Pics of my setup:
F