I have started hundreds of false scrapes over the years, but never had this happen. I bought a three bottle package of CODE RED for $10.00. I had three new white wicks that you put scent on then hang them on branches to attract deer. Well I pushed each one into the bottle and hung them on branches about 75 yards apart. Two days later there were fresh scrapes under each one and I have pictures of 5 different bucks hitting each one. I have good luck hanging them up in the past with Tink's 69 and other attractants, but never had any deer scrape and pee under them. Maybe you should try some.