Boston dropped the club requirement because of a lawsuit.
The only town I'm aware of that requires club membership is Brookline as part of the town's overall bigoted strategy of limiting access to rights and services to discourage non-affluent people from attempting to live in town.
Yeah, but look at how quickly small government conservatives agree to have the government step in and force women to have babies they dont want or didnt ask for, just cause it lines up with their religious beliefs.
You cant pick and choose which tyrannical laws you want to have.