On this we agree, a fence properly manned would be a deterrent, it worked along the East-German, West-German border, but to reiterate it would have to be manned and maintained.
I think the Border Patrol should develop a civilian auxiliary unit like the Civil Air Patrol, Coast Guard Auxiliary or in my very early youth the Ground Observer Corps. This unit would be responsible for observing and reporting illegal immigrants.
The other thing that should be considered is the guest worker program. We had it once in the 50's and 60's but the Johnson adminstration s**t canned it in '64 or '65. It was the Bracero Program and it allowed workers to come to the US for up to six months, then they had to return to Mexico. The families stayed back in the old country and for the most part the Braceros went back at the end of the six months because they knew that they would be coming back next year. I worked with them as a general laborer for the Bruce Church Ranch down in Yuma, Arizona, I chopped cotton and picked melons for the grand wage of 90 cents per hour in 1964...it was a great life experience as I was 15 at the time, and I really learned to appreciate the fact that I was an American.
The other thing is decidedly controversial: let's just grant amnesty to everyone that is here, but after the fence is up...no amnesty.
Let's lower the quota for legal admission to pre-1965 levels.
But first and foremost, let's build that fence.
Regards,
Mark