The results were accurate. Geddy Lee is one of the best. And he was also the vocalist and keyboard player. The others are rank amateurs in comparison. One trick ponies. Hacks that shouldn't even be mentioned in the same setting. It's like comparing Ringo Star to Mozart
Rush was one of the best shows ever. If you have seen them you would understand. And there is no one that even comes close to Neil Peart on drums.
After seeing them, you can't believe it is only 3 guys. Technically precise.
yeah anytime a magazine or website puts out a "best of " list of musicians its just that scrubs favorites...which if you put ten people in a room no one would come up with the same people. All personal preference.
I hate lists like this because they're so subjective. The scope of this list is pretty narrow, tilts to heavy metal and rewards flash and velocity (how many notes can I play in one minute) rather than musicianship and creativity. I can think of at least 10 other bassists who could arguably be on this list - Stanley Clarke, Bill Hayden, Jaco, Chris Squire...... Oh, and Geddy Lee never really impressed me.
Probably should of called it the top ten heavy metal bass players but anyway........John Paul Jones is an obvious omission. What about John McVie??? I always thought of Fleetwood/McVie as one of the best rhythm sections ever.
no love for Chris Squire in YES?
Until he showed up, the bass was just a plodding background line to keep the beat with. He turned it into a lead instrument, and showed people that there was a treble side to the sound too.
I think he had to use huge piano stings for his bass, as the normal bass strings of that day could not produce the rich harmonics he needed
Neither bass nor drums should ever be used as solo instruments, and solos on either are not a good indication of how good the player is.
Sure, it shows technical skill, but both instruments are designed to hold the band together while everyone else does their thing. The best players aren't showing out; they're being in the background, but doing such an awesome job of it that you have to go look them up.