-
If you enjoy the forum please consider supporting it by signing up for a NES Membership The benefits pay for the membership many times over.
Reason for a snub nose?
- Thread starter carib
- Start date
- Status
Concealability.
one-eyed Jack
Manufacturer
You can tell the moonbats that you carry a "Saturday Night Special". Jack.
What they said. I found myself carrying more often with the most convenient and comfortable setup. If I was running out of the house, I didn't feel like belting up with an IWB/1911 just to run down to the store, but it takes two seconds to toss a J frame into a pocket holster and slip it in my jacket, so I found myself carrying small revolvers often, with various methods. They offer great concealability, light weight and comfort. If I delivered pizzas in Harlem I might want a G17 with three spare mags, but my day to day and places I frequent are pretty low risk. I know bad stuff can happen anywhere, however Id take a WAG that most self defense scenarios take place at a distance of less than 10ft with no more than 3 shots fired and is over in a matter of seconds, and for that, a small revolver fits the bill. Besides, any gun on you is better than the three you left at the house.
For me, the only reason for a snubbie is pocket carry. If I'm going to carry in a belt holster, than I will carry something with a longer grip and a longer barrel that I can shoot more accurately.
In God We Trust
NES Member
Same here. A snub i.e. Is my go to for putzing around town. I'm usually too lazy to bother strapping on a holster, so I just throw the snub in my pocket.
I also live in a virtually crime free area. If I am going somewhere questionable, I carry a bigger gun.
And, to be honest, my snubbie sits in the safe when I pocket carry -- I use my Kahr PM9 instead. I shoot the PM9 better than my snubbie, it is faster to reload, and has higher capacity. YMMV.
- Joined
- Apr 24, 2005
- Messages
- 47,502
- Likes
- 33,495
I have a J frame (640) I carry in a Mitch Rosen pocket holster. This is very easy to conceal, and I don't have to worry about it being exposed, particularly if I bend over. Tactically, I can have my hand on the gun ready to draw without disclosing "gun" (particularly important in the climate of this state), and I could have the gun out and pointed before a n'ed do well realized I wasn't reaching into my pocket for money.
not new guy
NES Member
- Joined
- Dec 7, 2009
- Messages
- 36,033
- Likes
- 54,150
One of the guys on this forum who I respect as a shooter as much as anyone only carries snubbies. If you're good with it it's going to get you out of almost any situation just as well as a semi will.
Rugerfan
NES Member
All of the reasons given above are valid. I carry one as a primary when dressing light, and as a backup when I can.
If you really want to perfect your shooting ability with a revolver, a snubbie will offer you a significant challenge. The light weight combined with the short sight radius makes you realize just how good you are, or how much more practice you need!! Put a clay bird on the 25 yard berm at your club and have a go at it. When you get good at it, it impresses shooters watching you, and makes you a better shot to boot.
Get one. I have a few of them and full size revolvers as well. I shoot the snubbies about 2x as much as the full size. And I don't have to chase the brass.
If you really want to perfect your shooting ability with a revolver, a snubbie will offer you a significant challenge. The light weight combined with the short sight radius makes you realize just how good you are, or how much more practice you need!! Put a clay bird on the 25 yard berm at your club and have a go at it. When you get good at it, it impresses shooters watching you, and makes you a better shot to boot.
Get one. I have a few of them and full size revolvers as well. I shoot the snubbies about 2x as much as the full size. And I don't have to chase the brass.
Because they are easier to throw at your assailant after you miss.
Kidding aside, I highly recommend trying before buying. I can win a bullseye competition with a 6" revolver but always shoot snubbies like hell, at least not to my satisfaction. If I have to stand that close, why not a rock... Another post mentions shooting much better with a compact semi as well.
Kidding aside, I highly recommend trying before buying. I can win a bullseye competition with a 6" revolver but always shoot snubbies like hell, at least not to my satisfaction. If I have to stand that close, why not a rock... Another post mentions shooting much better with a compact semi as well.
MisterHappy
NES Member
- Joined
- Jul 28, 2009
- Messages
- 28,378
- Likes
- 17,544
It's better for the environment. Less metal used.
This and so you can impersonate Dirty Harry's obese inspector sidekick. I think this guy appeared in the original Dirty Harry and they made a joke about him not being able to jump a fence.
Edit: Yup, too much linguine...
https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Dirty_Harry
http://www.imfdb.org/wiki/Magnum_Force#Colt_Detective_Special
Last edited:
Lank
NES Member
Agreed, easier to reload when removing from in car lock box
I carry a snubbie because of reliability and the more concealable, organic lines of a revolver.
Sent from my 5054N using Tapatalk
Sent from my 5054N using Tapatalk
If you're not going to carry it, get something heavier with a longer barrel.
Lightweight guns are much harder on the little bones and soft tissue in your hand and wrist, because there's no mass to absorb the recoil.
I'd say the *only* reason to get a snubnose is because you intend to carry it a lot.
If you want something to shoot at the range, get a steel framed 4-6" barrel revolver: Better sights, longer sight radius, more fun to shoot.
Concealability and ease of use with draw backs of low round count and, if not using speed clips, bulky reloads.
There are those that carry revolvers due to decreased use of a hand or arm. I found out the hard way.
When I had a severe bicep rupture which resulted in nerve damage and limited range of motion I went to my old snub nose in the left hand pocket. I was happy to have it, know that I was already familiar with it, and could hit well enough that i was not carrying in vain.
Carrying left handed had me looking in to left handed revolvers and the added cost in new revolvers and holsters ruled that out. Not a settled outcome and another unexpected surgery soon.
Snubbies certainly have their place for certain people and circumstances.
There are those that carry revolvers due to decreased use of a hand or arm. I found out the hard way.
When I had a severe bicep rupture which resulted in nerve damage and limited range of motion I went to my old snub nose in the left hand pocket. I was happy to have it, know that I was already familiar with it, and could hit well enough that i was not carrying in vain.
Carrying left handed had me looking in to left handed revolvers and the added cost in new revolvers and holsters ruled that out. Not a settled outcome and another unexpected surgery soon.
Snubbies certainly have their place for certain people and circumstances.
Last edited:
ChevyGuy91
NES Member
- Joined
- Mar 25, 2008
- Messages
- 22,916
- Likes
- 23,496
I have always wanted a snubbie, but this is the real reason I don't have one. One of these days I will buy the cheaper, less safe version of the PM9 for lazy summer carry.
badshot101
NES Member
- Joined
- Apr 25, 2013
- Messages
- 218
- Likes
- 97
Everyone else has done a nice job talking about the pros and cons of snubbies. The only thing I want to add is to not get one of the lightweight 357's, or if you do don't shoot hot 357 out of it. They are beyond vicious.
Mine is a free state version, without the stupid safety.
Agreed.
I have an aluminum-framed 642. That is .38 Spcl +P. It weighs about 16 oz. And it is a nasty little bugger. Not fun at all to shoot with the factory grip. You can put a bigger, softer grip on it, but then you can't fit it in your pocket.
No way I would by one of the Scandium .357 Mag J-frames. They cost several hundred more and I don't want the pain.
If you do get a revolver, budget some $ for a trigger job. Greg Derr did a very nice trigger job on my Model 19.
Last edited:
I like mine fine, but it's definitely a love it or hate it gun. It just disappears into a pocket even in the summer though - perfect for t-shirt & shorts weather.
Try someone else's if you like recoil. A little patience usually will turn up a deal from someone who didn't try one first.
- Status
