Tuesday, November 28, 2006 Upton deer station irks some Police chief says site too close to playground
Upton deer station irks some
Police chief says site too close to playground
By Donna Boynton TELEGRAM & GAZETTE STAFF
Maybe I am wrong, but I think it’s poor judgment on their part.
Thomas Stockwell,
UPTON POLICE CHIEF
Picture
Wildlife biologist Richard Hartley, left, takes information yesterday near a playground in Upton about an 83-pound buck bagged by Steven Cooper of Franklin.
(T&G Staff/PAUL KAPTEYN)
Enlarge photo
UPTON— Police Chief Thomas Stockwell and state biologists locked horns yesterday over the location of a deer checkpoint station that can be seen from the town playground.
Police asked the biologists from the Central District office of the state Division of Fisheries & Wildlife to move the checkpoint after they received a complaint from a father of a young child. However, the biologists manning the checkpoint yesterday afternoon said parents did not complain to them and some parents actually used the opportunity as a nature lesson.
The checkpoint was in the parking lot of the Veterans of Foreign Wars hall on Route 140, adjacent to the town playground, and was in the same vicinity last year without any complaints, state biologists said. It was unclear whether they would return to the site today and Saturday, as scheduled. Yesterday was the first day of shotgun hunting season, and state officials estimated that 25 deer were brought to the Upton checkpoint throughout the day. Hunters are required by law to have their deer weighed and tagged at a state checkpoint. Shotgun season lasts until Saturday.
Yesterday morning a father called the police to complain about the location of the scale and the small puddles of blood that were being left by freshly killed deer.
The playground was used yesterday by many parents with preschool-age children, and when Chief Stockwell visited the site yesterday, there were about 20 children in the playground while a shot deer was being weighed.
After receiving the complaint, Chief Stockwell dispatched an officer to ask the biologists to move to a more appropriate spot. The biologists told the officer that they had permission from the VFW to use the parking lot and were not intending to move.
The chief, hoping to resolve the matter, went to speak to the biologists himself and said he was rudely rebuffed.
“I told them I did not think this was an appropriate place to be doing this, and they replied that was only my opinion,” Chief Stockwell said. “They said they had permission and that they were going to stay.”
“Maybe I am wrong, but I think it’s poor judgment on their part,” said Chief Stockwell. He said he knows that gathering the information from the deer is central to their job. “There is a better place for this other than the center of town, next to a playground. They certainly wouldn’t set up next to an elementary school.”
Chief Stockwell suggested the checkpoint be moved to a state rest area on Route 140, near the Upton line, or in the parking lot across from the Grafton Flea Market, which is closed this time of year. Chief Stockwell said he called the Division of Fisheries & Wildlife’s regional supervisor, who listened to his concerns, but without reaching a resolution.
“If you put one of these in the center of Mendon, in the center of Hopedale or in the center of Milford, you would run into the same problem,” Chief Stockwell said. “I just think it is poor judgment.”
State biologists said they set up in the parking lot to avoid causing traffic problems along Route 140. The deer checkpoint is established in conjunction with Fin & Feather Sports, on Route 140, explained Bridgett McAlice, a game biologist with the Central District office, and Richard Hartley, who also is with the Division of Fisheries & Wildlife.
“Because this was the first day of shotgun season, we were expecting a large volume and didn’t want to back up cars and traffic on Route 140, so we moved over here,” Ms. McAlice said.
The scale used to weigh the deer is typically kept by the door to the Fin & Feather store, Ms. McAlice said. The checkpoint initially started in the parking lot directly across the street from the store, but it was moved after Ms. McAlice and Mr. Hartley were informed that the parking lot was the playground parking lot, and as such was town property. The two moved to the far end of the VFW parking lot, next to the playground.
After the police spoke with them, they moved to another location on the VFW parking lot, near the Christmas tree sale stand about 50 feet away, so as not to be so close to the playground. Though the scale had been moved, there were still areas of wet blood where the checkpoint had been located.
Ms. McAlice said they were under the impression they had the permission of the VFW to use the lot, which was communicated to them through the owner of the sporting store, but they were told yesterday afternoon they did not have permission.
Mr. Hartley said they were never approached by any parent with a complaint; rather, parents seemed to welcome the weigh station.
“Numerous parents did come up with the kids to observe the situation, to touch the deer,” Mr. Hartley said. “In fact, they were fascinated by it. They were very interested by what we were doing and used this as an educational experience. … I wouldn’t have construed that as parents being upset or concerned. Kids weren’t upset by any means.”
Mr. Hartley said that handling a shot or killed deer will result in the inevitable occasional drop of blood.
Checkpoints are publicized, and if the checkpoint has to be moved or is closed, hunters are required to search out another, Ms. McAlice said.