Help me decide which 9mm to get

[ldi]

His choice was the Sig 320 or VP9

I say 320

I say let PO try both and pick the one that feels like an extension of his arm (more natural)
There is no bad choice here.

 

[S&W45]

Went with the 320c over the vp9 when it first became available in Ma and have about 500 down the pipe. Great gun! A pleasure to shoot and very accurate. My FS M&P9 quickly found a new home. Also, Grayguns sells a nice trigger kit if you feel the need.

 

[rwl1955]

I've got the Glock 19 and 17 and want to get into another 9mm, trying to decide between the HK VP9 or the Sig P320. Only Sig I've ever fired was a LE Sig 40 and the trigger pull sucked, I've never fired a HK before so nothing to really go by other than online reviews so figured I'd ask here. All my handguns are in the same category, Carry, Range, HD etc.. I shoot my guns and rotate them in what I carry as well. Thanks in advance

******
I just purchased the Sig 320C but read an article on the VP9 and the author raved about it.

 

[Dip Dungles]

Owned both and ended up selling the VP9. Every time I shoot the 320C it puts a smile on my face. I have had a bunch of Sig's and this one is one of my favorites.

 

[Point37]

I say try both and see which is the more comfortable.

^^^this...i have shot both but not back to back...i liked them both...the vp9 mag release is a little weird but i found it accurate...the 320 was nice and the interchangeable frames are a nice feature but i found it a little wide...i don't think you could go wrong with either...as others have said the canik should be on the list as well for price and what seems to be good reliability thus far

 

[Old Glory]

Definitely try both...but if you can try a metal framed 9mm you should.

 

[Dennis in MA]

Gitcherself a Glock and ditch that sissy-plated nickel pistol.

 

[Davejb]

Gitcherself a Glock and ditch that nickel plated sissy pistol.

FIFY

 

[thormx538]

Neither. Buy a STI Edge.

I'm a Glock guy. I've shot plenty of P320s and while the trigger is nice and the modular concept is nifty, they just feel tall in my hand compared to the Glock. I doubt I'll ever buy one.

Can't help you on the VP9 at all. It looks like a Walther P22 -- that's all I've got

 

[TomMontana]

Love how these threads always go. OP asked for help choosing between an Accord and a Camry. Then gets recommendations for a BMW 5 series.

 

[Dennis in MA]

FIFY

It was better the way I wrote it. LOL

For the OP - I'm so Glock-centric that owning a non-Glock striker-fired pistol is just too strange to me. The Glock is not the most comfortable pistol, but after about 20 years, I'm sorta stuck with it, mentally. I have confidence that bullets are going where I told them to with the platform. Other ones, my brain gets in the way and I just can't get a "feel" for the grip. Confidence drops.

Buy what you want/like. Screw all of us. Your subconscious is likely just mining NES for posts that confirm what you already want to do, so you are good to go either way. Good luck!

- - - Updated - - -

Neither. Buy a STI Edge.

I'm a Glock guy. I've shot plenty of P320s and while the trigger is nice and the modular concept is nifty, they just feel tall in my hand compared to the Glock. I doubt I'll ever buy one.

Can't help you on the VP9 at all. It looks like a Walther P22 -- that's all I've got

YES!

All Sig's feel tall in the hand. High bore axis. Not that it's "bad" but it feels and looks funny.

But there is something to be said of Dana Scully wandering around some abandoned warehouse holding a 239. That has to be over 15 years ago. LOL

 

[wahsben]

I like this one: https://www.wilsoncombat.com/edc-x9/

 

[BKM5]

I'd go with either a Sphinx or a CZ. Both have full length aluminum rails instead of inserts. I could throw my sphinx in the air with a string attached to the trigger and still hit the bulls eye.

https://youtu.be/UuA-92-koYs

My mind is blown

Sent from my XT1650 using Tapatalk

 

[plynch113]

Beretta 92
Sig p226
Hk USP

 

[mikelawtown]

I've got the Glock 19 and 17 and want to get into another 9mm, trying to decide between the ---->HK VP9 or the Sig P320.<--- Only Sig I've ever fired was a LE Sig 40 and the trigger pull sucked, I've never fired a HK before so nothing to really go by other than online reviews so figured I'd ask here. All my handguns are in the same category, Carry, Range, HD etc.. I shoot my guns and rotate them in what I carry as well. Thanks in advance

 

[Old Glory]

Shot a VP9 today...it was very nice. Group of 5 rounds at 25 feet:

 

[ldi]

LOL

 

[Bdh821]

9mm 1911

 

[Slotheadslim]

I haven't had the pleasure of shooting a P320 but my VP9 is my favorite gun.