Cheap bastards? Really? $150 for initiation and $150 for dues. So that's $300 so far. Harvard Sportsmen's club is about an hour drive each way from where I live so that's a good amount in gas if I go more than once a week. Doesn't seem like a practical or cost effective option for myself. For your information, I own 4 pistols and 2 rifles. I would not consider myself a "cheap bastard" as I have invested more than $2500 in my collection. I was simply asking if there was a cheaper alternative to the places that make you pay for all the extra amenities. I clearly stated I was only interested in an outdoor range that I could use to practice. Why would I want to pay more than $300 a year if all I am looking for is a simple pistol and rifle range. Maybe next time you could just refrain from acting like a pompous asshat and just allow for a harmless question.
Although I am not familiar with the cost of the various clubs in your area.
- Keep in mind that the initiation fee is a 1x only fee, so if you are a member for a number of years, that amortizes to a noise level cost.
- IIRC someone stated that there is a work-off option at Harvard (and perhaps some other clubs) which can reduce your cost if you invest some time.
- A strong club is one that offers numerous events, options as that brings more members and thus results in a strong treasury to keep up whatever infrastructure they have or desire plus offers some political clout when some NIMBY tries to shut down your club by proposing by-law changes in the town, etc.
- Over time your interests might broaden and having that capability to expand your interests without having to join another club is something you might consider as beneficial.
- $200-300 up-front may seem very expensive, but paying $20.00/hour adds up to exceed the typical $100-150/year dues of most clubs rather rapidly . . . you just may not realize it because it is a "slow leak" in your wallet.
- My only personal experiences with pay ranges has been S&W (now closed), AFS (teaching a class there) and observing MFL in action (never shot there). There are a lot more people on the range exhibiting unsafe practices (pointing guns towards others) than you will typically find at a club. There is a wait to get a shooting lane (MFL is awesome but I've been there when people are waiting 30-60 minutes for a shooting lane), so if your time is valuable this might be a consideration. There is a clock ticking and a cash register clicking away on your time at the range. I've belonged to 4 clubs over >35 years and never had to wait for a shooting lane/position, my cost doesn't increase if I spend more than 1 hour on the line, fewer people are pointing guns at me and I prefer shooting outdoors which is an option not available at any area pay range. Three of those clubs allowed 24x7 access to their indoor ranges (4th club has no indoor facilities at all), so I don't have to worry about business hours.
- I do agree with you about travel time to get to a range/club. Definite consideration! I rarely go to BR&P since it takes me twice as long to get there as to MF&G.
Some comments about my club/range experiences over the years.
- I'd pay more to NOT have clueless people, aspiring gangbangers, etc. pointing guns at me on a range!!!
- My first club had fishing, which I had no interest in, but the dues were similar to other clubs without fishing (they actually charged more to fishermen to pay for stocking the ponds). I started out shooting .22 rifle and then pistol, later took up trap and skeet. In 1998 I decided to get an AR-15 before they were totally banned and since their outdoor range didn't allow CF rifle, I went looking for another club. Since the indoor range had no working air intake, it made it a health hazard to shoot indoors, so first I stopped all indoor shooting and later quit this club. Small club where we never had adequate money in the treasury, so club upgrades weren't typically done.
- My next club (BR&P) had 2700 members when I joined (now >5K) and a very healthy treasury, 2 indoor ranges (now both HEPA filtered) for a total of 23 positions and 7 outdoor ranges. Unless there is a match, I've never encountered a wait to shoot. Property is well cared for and when a decision to upgrade something is made, it is put out to bid and done by hired contractors. It is run like a business.
- The other 2 clubs were to fill a need of being closer and allowing some tactical shooting, reactive targets, etc. Due to the political leadership, I quit one of them and although we don't have any indoor facilities at MF&G, I am very happy with the freedom allowed on the outdoor ranges and the efforts that resulted in building a short training range for us instructors to use without inconveniencing the membership.
YMMV but I hope the above gives you pause to consider what you really want to do and assists you in making the right decision for you.