All my social ammo is JHP, and I wouldn't use anything else, unless it's a small round like .25 ACP that doesn't have enugh energy to expand the hollow point.
Honestly I've just read a few articles on this guy and while it's a VERY bad situation, it sounds like a clean shooting. The man's dogs charge fish, he pulls his gun and fires a warning shot to scare them off (This actully appears to be a good use of a warning shot, as a dog might not understand what a gun is...but the report and a hole in the ground does clarify things a bit). After the warning shot now he's being charged by the homeless man and he has a gun in his hand.
We all know that it's BS propiganda when somebody tells you "Your gun will only be taken away from you" but getting in a scuffle with a drawn gun it's a very distinct reality. So he shouted warnings, but did not risk loosing control of his gun.
Would I have done it differently? Dunno. But his story does smell like a clean kill.
I would think it's bad enugh to have to shoot in self defence....I think it's only worse when you shoot an unarmed attacker (like the guy in Seattle).
-Weer'd Beard