I have done more than a few now and they have all gone nothing but smooth. Everyone I met has been from this site. I just did one tonight with another board member. It was his first FTF, we actually met at his office and everything went smoothly. I know he was a little unsure being his first transfer but I know I was for mine as well. I printed out the FA-10 and already had my information pre-filled out and he filled in his info then we filled out the gun info together.
All the other transfers I have done have been in a car in a parking lot. I did do one at the police station one time but that's because the person was a police officer so we did the transfer in his office. It just happened to be in the same room they did my finger printing for my license.
I just had this convo with a friend of mine last week. He has never bought a gun FTF but I set him up with someone from this board a little while back to sell his G19. He was all nervous but everything went smoothly. I think he carried 3 guns on him plus the one he was selling. I don't know what he was thinking.
He says well what if the guy gives me a fake license or tries to hold me up which i highly doubt would happen but its possible. Just about everyone you meet is proud to have their LTC and no one wants to screw it up.
I told my friend I don't get really nervous meeting someone for a gun transfer. Now its normal, just a matter of finding a location thats convienient for both people.
This same friend sent me to Springfield, MA this past spring with a pocket full of cash to pick up a motor from some kids for his race car and I told him that one I was a little nervous with.
He didn't see a problem with that however. I didn't know who the kids were. There were more of them than myself and the person I was with. It all went smoothly in the end though.